Law location

The High Court of South Africa

Eastern Cape Division/Oos-Kaapse Afdeling

Direct access to this site can be obtained by connecting to: http://www.ru.ac.za/static/ecd.

This sketch is taken from Bench and Bar by George Randel and is used with the kind permission of the artist, Mrs D Randel.

The judgments currently on display are the original judgments in MS Word format and in Adobe Acrobat (PDF) format.

Date	Case Number	Case Name and Subject Matter
2008	Back to Top
30/05/2008	R: 3050/06	B. Van der Linde & Another v The Road Accident Fund H.J Liebenberg Action for Damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
27/05/2008	R: 31/08	The State v Zwelethu Njalavu Greenland AJ Criminal Trial - Rape Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document (Unavailable)
23/05/2008	R: 1471/95	Johnston Currie v The Road Accident Fund Jansen J Quantum damages judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
23/05/2008	R: CA & R 244/07	Ronaldo Magidigidi v The State Chetty J, Roberson AJ Appeal against sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
23/05/2008	R: CA & R 238/2007	Bulelani Fosi v The State Chetty J, Roberson AJ Rape - appeal against sentence of 15 years imprisonment. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
16/05/2008	R: 6104/07	Gay Booysen v Geoffrey Lyster Warren-Smith Jansen J Exception by the plaintiff to the defendant's plea and counterclaim. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
16/05/2008	R: 55/2008	The State v Zincamile Mandla Nongingi Mthembu A.J The defendant was convicted of an offence referred to in Part 1 of Schedule 2, and as a result, the matter was referred in terms of the provisions of Section 52(1)(b) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 105 of 1997 for sentence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
15/05/2008	R: CA & R 367/07	Danny Boy Mango v The State Pickering J, Froneman J Leave to Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
15/05/2008	R: 929/08	Uncedo Service Taxi Association v Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality & Another Jones J Application for an interim interdict - the applicatn was not able to prove that the right upon which it relied was prima facie established though open to some doubt Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
14/05/2008	R: 1427/06	Firstrand Bank Limited v Sybil N Mayeza Greenland AJ Civil Trial: Plaintiff sued Defendant for return of monies allegedly stolen whilst she was in the employ of the the Plaintiff Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document (unavailable)
13/05/2008	R: CA & R 390/07	Thembisile Mahokoto v The State Somyalo JP, Foneman J, Plasket J This is an appeal against a sentence of 21 years imprisonment imposed on the appellant by the trial judge after the appellant had been convicted of housebreaking with intent to steal and rape Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
13/05/2008	R: 2092/2007	The National Director of Public Prosecutions vs Duhanco Labour Contractors (Pty) Ltd & Another Dambuza J A Provisional Restraint order was granted against the respondents in terms of Section 26(1) as read with Section 74(1)(a) of the Prevention of Organised Crime Act No. 121 of 1998 Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
13/05/2008	R: 202/2006	Douglas Thembeni Manina v The Minister of Safety and Security and Another Greenland AJ Application: This is an application, as made clear by Applicant's attorney at the hearing, in terms of the possessory remedy provided by the mandament van spolie. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document (unavailable)
12/05/2008	R: 945/08	Earl Godfrey Appolis v The Commissioner of Correctional Services & 3 Others Jones J Urgent Parole application Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
12/05/2008	R: 979/2006	Pumlani Patrick Peter v The Road Accident Fund Greenland AJ Civil trial for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document (unavailable)
09/05/2008	R: 1089/07	Bolekwa Nokeke v The Minister of Safety and Security & Another Plasket J The plaintiff sued the defendants for damages arising from an alleged assault on her, an insult uttered to her shortly after she was arrested and an unlawful arrest. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/05/2008	R: 2369/07	Firstrand Bank v Shane David Olivier A.R Erasmus Summary Judgment Application: Section 85 of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/05/2008	R: CA & R 320/06	William Wilfred Burger v The State Foneman J, Plasket J Appeal: The appellant was convicted of assault with intent to commit grievous bodily harm and escaping from lawful custody, having pleaded guilty to these offences. He was sentenced to 12 months imprisonment. He appeals against the sentence imposed. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/05/2008	R: 20080069	The State v Siseko Bam Plasket J, Roberson AJ Review Judgment: The accused was convicted of contravening s 4(b) of the Drugs and Drug Trafficking Act 140 of 1992. He was sentenced to 12 months imprisonment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/05/2008	R: 20070177	The State v Loyiso Sisi Plasket J, Roberson AJ Automatic review judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
05/05/2008	R: 676/2007	Trevor Frederick King v Magdalena Josina King Plasket J This application was brought in terms of rule 41(1)(c) of the Uniform Rules for an order, directing the respondent to pay the applicant's costs in an action that he, the respondent, instituted against the applicant and later withdrew Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
05/05/2008	R: 6113/2007	Bruce Ehrlich v Minister of Correctional Services & Another Plasket J The applicant, a setenced prisoner, applied to review and set aside a decision taken to deny him access to a gym in the prison. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
29/04/2008	R: 1647/2007	André Herselman v Nedcor Bank & Another Dambuza J Applicant seeks transfer of certain immovable property to him. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
24/04/2008	R: 1140/2006	Member of the Executive Council for Housing, Provincial Government and Traditional Affairs f Dr Dlova Legal Aid and Corporate Services & 6 Others Petse ADJP Application Judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
24/04/2008	R: 890/2007	The MEC, Department of Education & Another v Daniel Mlamli Bodlani Petse ADJP Judgment on Application for Leave to Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
17/04/2008	R: 1527/05	Bonisile James Mzeku & 248 Others v Volkswagen (SA) (Pty) Ltd & Another Jones J Exception - particulars of claim claiming damages for breach of contract from a trade union for failing to prevent its members from engaging in an illegal strike, thereby causing them to lose their employment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
10/04/2008	R: 176/07	Benedict Mduma v Die Staat Liebenberg R, Eksteen AJ Die appellant, as beskuldigde 2, het saam met sy broer, Leon Mduma in die streekhof tereg gestaan op in aanklag van moord. Beide is skuldig bevind en die appellant is tot 15 jaar gevangenisstraff gevonnis terwyl sy broer tot 18 jaar gevangenisstraf gevonnis is. die appellant kom nou in hoër beroep teen sy skuldigbevinding en vonnis. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
10/04/2008	R: 48/07	Edwin Lessing v The State Liebenberg J, Eksteen AJ Appeal: The appellant was convicted in the Regional court of robbery with aggravating circumstances and sentenced to 15 years imprisonment in terms of the provisions of Act 105 of 1997. the appellant comes on appeal against the sentence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
03/04/2008	R: 2607/2004	The Baron Camillo Agasim-Pereira of Fulwood v Johnnic Media Investments Ltd & 2 Others Chetty J Opposed application: Defamation - Exception - defamation action - quasi innuendo specific meanings attributed Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
03/04/2008	R: 402/07	Ekuphumleni Resort Pty Ltd and Another v E.C. Gambling Board NO Leach J Both applicants, had submitted bids for a casino license. Dissatisfied with the award to the third and fourth respondents, they launched legal proceedings seeking an order to review to set aside the first respondent's decision in this regard. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document (unavailable)
27/03/2008	R: EL 155/2003 ECD: ECD 351/2003	Ettiene Van Rensburg v Condoprops 42 (Pty) Limited Leach J Special plea in which the defendant contends, firstly that the plaintiff, Ettiene Van Rensburg lacks locus standi and, secondly, in the alternative, that the claim has prescribed. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document (unavailable)
20/03/2008	R: 405/2008	Transnet Limited v Proud Heritage Properties (Pty) Ltd and 2 Others Chetty J Opposed Application - National Ports Authority - Statutory duty to operate and maintain navigational aids Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/03/2008	R: 468/2008	Maclear Financial Services Pty Ltd v Nicolaas Johannes Human Chetty J Opposed Application - Restraint of Trade Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/03/2008	R: 4200/2005	Nomsa Joyce Siwani v The Road Accident Fund & 1 Other Chetty J Action for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
18/03/2008	R: 1210/2006	Mbizana Local Municipality v Mbizana Village Senior Secondary School & 2 Others Chetty J Application for leave to appeal - local authority - provincial government - land rezoning Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/02/2008	R: 3099/2006	Jeanette Rautenbach v William Godfrey Rautenbach Chetty J Divorce - forfeiture of patrimonial benefits of the marriage - duration of marriage Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
14/02/2008	R: 6125/07	Susan Jane Hattingh v Michael Gordon Hattingh Chetty J Application for maintenance pendente lite. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
2007	Back to Top
20/12/2007	R: 607/2007	No. Italy Phindiwe Mtirara v Landmark Mthatha (Pty) Ltd & 10 Others Petse ADJP This is an application for leave to appeal against the whole judgment which was dismissed by Petse ADJP with costs on 23 May 2007. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/12/2007	R: CA & R 82/2007 ECJ:	Antoinette Saayman v The State Pickering J, Nepgen J Leave to Appeal against sentence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
06/12/2007	R: 418/2005 ECJ:	Vuyani Mlatsheni v Road Accident Fund Plasket J Civil Case: A claim for damages arising from a motor accident, the merits had been settled on the basis of 80/20 percent apportionment. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
06/12/2007	R: CA392/2005 ECJ:	Mbelelo Danster v The State Plasket J, Froneman J, Leach J Leave to appeal against a conviction for murder and the illegal possession of a firearm. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
23/11/2007	R: A 120/07 ECJ:	Noxolo Halu v Theodore Thabo Revelas J & Pac Rowan AJ Leave to appeal against the decision of a magistrate in Tsolo, to dismiss the appellant's application for the rescission of a default judgment dated 29 October 2004. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
23/11/2007	R: A 105/07 ECJ:	Mzunzima Sonjica & Others v Anderson Nongudle Mapasa Revelas J & Pac Rowan AJ Leave to appeal the discharge of a rule nisi interdicting them inter alia, from utilizing certain land leased by the respondent. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
17/09/2007	R: CA 303/2006 ECJ: 189/2007	The Body Corporate of Algoa Hof & 13 Others v EM Scheepers Sandi J, Dawood J Sectional title scheme – established for residential purposes only – conversion of sectional title unit from residential to business – consent of all the owners not obtained in order to convert unit as required by section 44 (1)(g) of the Sectional Titles Act 95 of 1986 – an application to the magistrate to convert the residential unit to business was granted - on appeal the magistrate’s decision was reversed. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
13/09/2007	R: A80/07 ECJ: 192/2007	Eastern Cape Development Corporation v Mlungisi July Kroon J, Van Zyl J, Dawood AJ Appeal: Against an order made by Miller J consequent upon an application brought by the respondent. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
06/09/2007	R: 1357/2005	Nondwendwe Kama & Others v Nombulelo Anoria Kama & Another Petse J, Paterson AJ, Van Zyl J Appeal Judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document (unavailable)
06/09/2007	R: 1251/06 ECJ: 187/2007	MEC: Department of Roads & Transport v LM Giyose Froneman J, Somyalo J, Sandi J Leave to appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
30/08/2007	R: 496/2006 ECJ: 188/2007	RJC Molyneux v LN Wicks and Others Erasmus J Civil Procedure – Interim interdict pending action Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
31/07/2007	R: 485/2007 ECJ: 191/2007	Phumla Dwane-Alpman v The Premier, Eastern Cape Kroon J The applicant instituted proceedings as a matter of urgency on the grounds of unfair dismissal. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/07/2007	R:878/02, 1376/02, 1377/02, 1523/02 ECJ: 179/2007	MP King & 92 Others v The Attorneys Fidelity Fund Plasket J The plaintiffs sought to hold the defendant liable for their loss in terms of s 26(a) of the Attorneys Act 53 of 1979 on the basis that the money they had placed in the discounting scheme had been stolen by a practising attorney after having been entrusted to him in the course of his practice as an attorney. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/07/2007	R: CA & R 69/06 ECJ: 190/2007	Lester Gallant v The State Revelas J, Plasket J Appeal: The applicant instituted an appeal against a conviction. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
28/06/2007	R: 172/2007 ECJ: EL265/07 & ECD565/07	First Rand Bank Limited v Raphael Lenea & Another Leach J Summary Judgment on a mortgage bond - Court entitled to grant an order declaring the mortgaged property executable Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
28/06/2007	R: 2535/06 ECJ: 171/2007	Road Accident Fund v Frank Lifson Leach J Application to compel Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
22/06/2007	R: CA & R 54/07 ECJ: 176/2007	Brett Stevens v The State Froneman J Leave to Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
22/06/2007	R: CA 86/06 ECJ: 168/2007	Road Accident Fund v OH Ronaasen NO on behalf of Juan Joubert Jones J, Chetty J and Beshe J Damages Claim: Loss of earnings and earning capacity Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/06/2007	R: 1133/06 ECJ: 166/2007	Louis Slabbert v Alec Brett Jones J Application for Rescission: Rescission of an order striking out a defence and a judgment by default - good cause - applicant failing to show good cause. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/06/2007	R: EL188/05; ECD488/05 ECJ: 167/2007	HCW Jordaan & Another v Z Msweli Plasket J In a special plea, the defendant (the seller) pleaded that two clauses of an agreement of sale were suspensive conditions in his favour and that they had not been fulfilled or waived by him. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
18/06/2007	R:CA 186/06 ECJ: 163/2007	Carl Wynand Rautenbach v Ongegunde Vryheid cc Jones J & Dambuza J Appeal: Via ex necessitate - Access to fisherman's cottage on coastal land Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
14/06/2007	R: 711/2002 ECJ: 164/2007	The Minister of Labour v The Fedics Group (Pty) Revelas J The applicant seeks to rescind a judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
14/06/2007	R: 2737/06 ECJ: 157/2007	Bennett Pringle (Pty) Ltd v Johannes Frederick Dreyer & 3 Others Jones J Administrative review of decision of fencing board Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
14/06/2007	R: CA 304/06 ECJ:	Violet Nelson v Minister of Safety and Security Jones J, Schoeman J Wrongful arrest and detention Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
14/06/2007	R: CA232/06 ECJ: 159/2007	The Road Accident Fund v Catherine Ferndale Jones J, Dambuza J, Matthee AJ Full Bench Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
12/06/2007	R: 3004/06 ECJ: 161	Stephanus Johannes Muller v Annemarie Muller & 1 Ander Jansen R Aksie vir afrokkeling Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
12/06/2007	R: 2526/06 ECJ: 162/2007	Minister van Veiligheid en Sekuriteit v Laurika Louise Vermeulen Jansen R Aansoek om verlof om te appelleer. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/06/2007	R: A-97/2002	The Minister of Justice & Constitutional Development v Mbuyiseli Rozani Petse ADJP and Conjwa AJ Appeal Judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/06/2007	R: 778/2002 ECJ: 160/2007	Road Accident Fund v Sabata Gobingca Sandi J, Plasket J, Beshe J Full Bench Appeal: Action for Damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
06/06/2007	R: 1066/05 ECJ: 177/2007	ZS SvN Syndicate v 43 Air School & 1 Other Froneman J Civil Case: Apportionment of fault between licensed aerodrome operator and pilot who landed on unserviceable landing strip and crashed as a result – assessment of negligence where expert skill involved: expert views and professional standards of great importance but not determinative of issue of negligence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
05/06/2007	R: 2586/06 ECJ: 165/2007	Stutterheim High School v The Member of Executive Council, Department of Education, Eastern Cape Province & 4 Others Plasket J Application to Compel Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
31/05/2007	R: 1790/04 ECJ: 147/2007	Intertrade Two (Pty) Ltd v MEC for Roads and Public Works , Eastern Cape & Another Plasket J The appellant had tendered for certain contracts. It was common cause that no final decision had been taken. Two issues arose for decision on appeal. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
30/05/2007	R: 1463/06 ECJ: 155/2007	Thomas Stanley Alexander Krog v Padongeluksfonds Jansen R Skadevergoedingsaksie Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
29/05/2007	R: 7539/05 ECJ: 156/2007	Andy Gilbert Iverson v Road Accident Fund Mhlantla J Claim for Damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
18/05/2007	R: 105/2007 ECJ: 148/2007	Andile Gladman Jela & Another v Gloria Nobuhle Madikane Plasket J In an application for the eviction of the respondent in terms of s4 of the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
15/05/2007	R: 853/07 ECJ: 146/2007	Sydney Goniwe v Sipiwo Mawindi & Another Plasket J Application and counter-application concerning the right to bury a deceased person Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
11/05/2007	R: 20070280 ECJ: 143/2007	The State v Simphiwe Ngqolombe-Faba Plasket J and Revelas J Review Judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
11/05/2007	R: 105/06 ECJ: 144/2007	Luvuyo Cornelius Matini & Another v The State Plasket J and Revelas J Criminal Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
24/04/2007	R: 2839/06B ECJ:151/2007	Gareth Prins v Minister of Correctional Services Plasket J Application to compel respondent to provide adequate medical treatment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
24/04/2007	R: 333/07 ECJ: 150/2007	Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality v Nkosinathi Paul Jikeka & 2 Others Plasket J Costs claim Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
24/04/2007	R: 699/07 ECJ: 149/2007	The National Director of Public Prosecutions v Edwin Evril Stander & 7 Others Plasket J Application for a preservation of property order in terms of s38 of the Prevention of Organised Crime Act 121 of 1998. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
24/04/2007	R: 514/07 ECJ: 145/2007	Boniswa Leonora Klass & 2 Others Plasket J Ex Parte Application Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/04/2007	R: 2567/01 ECJ: 142/07	Christiaan Wynand Johannes Botes NO & Maryka Botes NO v James John Shamley Jones J Special plea of novation – whether on the facts the original cause of action was extinguished by a series of further agreements which failed but which were made in an attempt to keep the original transaction alive. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/04/2007	R: 3242/06 ECJ: 141/07	The Reivelo Leppa Trust & Ebenaeser Olivier v Johan Hendrick Kritzinger Jones J Rectification a contract for the sale of land – claim for rectification by the inclusion of a portion of the land under separate title omitted from the written contract of sale by mutual error. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
05/04/2007	R: 823/04 ECJ: 139/2007	Leon Montie Fortuin v RAF Jones J Quantum of damages for a fractured right tibia and soft tissue damage to the right knee joint. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
03/04/2007	R: 1668/06 ECJ: 093/2007	Wilma Emmerentia van Rensburg NO & Another v Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality & 7 Others Froneman J Dispute between private neighbours about buildings on urban property. The dispute also has a public character because of the local authority’s failure to act in accordance with the provisions of the restrictive title conditions relating to the property. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
02/04/2007	R: 3350/2006 ECJ: 092/2007	Nic's Joinery Close Corporation v Karen Tilana Adlem & 2 others Leach J A plaintiff who wishes to apply for summary judgment is required by Rule 32(2) to file an affidavit Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
29/03/2007	R: 2022/06 ECJ: 89/2007	Lisomzi Siyabulela Kalimashe v Bongile Glenda Macanda Leach J Custody of minor children Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
28/03/2007	R:CC1/2006 (SECLD) ECJ: 51/2007	The State v Mfundo Ngaphi Plasket J Judgment on sentence; Rape and Robbery Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
23/03/2007	R: CC26/2007 ECJ: 153/2007	Die Staat v Theoniel Destination Smith Plasket R Vonnis Oplegging Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/03/2007	R: CC26/2007 ECJ: 154/2007	Die Staat v Theoniel Destination Smith Plasket R Uitspraak Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
15/03/2007	R: 2735 & 2748/06 ECJ: 097/2007	Khulisa Plant Hire & Finance (Pty) Ltd v First Rand Bank t/a Bell Equipment Froneman J Application to oppose liquidation Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Tagged Image File Format Document
15/03/2007	R: 226/2007 ECJ: 095/2007	Lee-Anne Ruth Gernetzky v Derek Barnard Gernetzky & 2 Others Froneman J Opposed application where the applicant seeks confirmation of a rule granted as a matter of urgency on 15 February 2007. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Tagged Image File Format Document
15/03/2007	R: 125/2006 ECJ: 094/2007	Ashlyn Telling v The State Pickering J and Dambuza J Appellant was convicted in the Regional Court, Patensie, of culpable homicide and was thereafter sentenced to undergo 6 years imprisonment of which 2 years imprisonment was suspended for 5 years on certain conditions. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
13/03/2007	R: 1576/06 (SECLD) ECJ:	Bluelilliesbush Dairy Farming (Pty) Ltd & Another v The Minister of Agriculture & Others Jansen J An application concerning the compensation payable to the applicants in terms of the Animal Diseases Act, No. 35 of 1984 for tuberculosis infected cattle or suspected infected cattle slaughtered in terms of the provisions of the Act. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/03/2007	R: 20070119 ECJ: 152/2007	The State v Lesizi Ndonga Plasket J and Dambuza J Review Judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/03/2007	R: 508/2006 ECJ: 88/2007	Nokuzola Elizabeth Feni (born Mlengana) v Zanele Kondzani Pickering J Damages Claim Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
02/03/2007	R: CC06/07 ECJ: 103/2007	The State v Mandilakhe Marhotya & Thanduxolo Lufele (Sentence) Plasket J Criminal Proceeding Sentence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
02/03/2007	R: CC06/07 ECJ: 102/2007	The State v Mandilakhe Marhotya & Thanduxolo Lufele (Judgment) Plasket J Criminal Proceeding Judgment. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
22/02/2007	R: 795/05 ECJ: 096/2007	Pierre Christiaan Jonker v The Road Accident Fund Froneman J Determination of total damages to be awarded to the plaintiff Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Tagged Image File Format Document
22/02/2007	R: 2723/2006 ECJ: 100/2007	Cindy Edwards v Neil Andrew Arnold Plasket J, Revelas J Application to set aside a settlement agreement that had been made an order of court. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/02/2007	R: CA & R 324/05 ECJ: 098/2007	Alex Khaya Swarts v The State Froneman J Appeal against sentence and judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Tagged Image File Format Document
09/02/2007	R: Review No. 20060988 ECJ: 105/07	The State v Andisiwe Melani Plasket J, Pickering J Review Judgment. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
09/02/2007	R: CA 403/05 CA 405/05 ECJ: 106/07	Road Accident Fund v G.P Van Rhyn (CA 403/05) & F.J Van Rhyn (CA 405/05) Plasket J, Jones J Appeals against quantum for general damages – Test for interference on appeal re-stated – Held that there was no basis for interference with the awards of damages made by the court. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/02/2007	R: CA 352/2006	Whitey Bruintjies vs The State Pickering J, Froneman J, Plasket J Appellant was convicted of rape in the Regional Court, Humansdorp, pursuant to his plea of guilty. Maqubela AJ imposed the minimum sentence of life imprisonment. Appellant now appeals with the requisite leave of the Court a quo to the Full Bench of this Division. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/02/2007	R: CA 197/2006	Mncedisi Snoti vs The State Pickering J, Froneman J, Plasket J Appeal to the Full Bench against a sentence of life imprisonment imposed by Jones J upon appellant pursuant to a conviction of rape in the South East Cape Local Division. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/02/2007	ECJ: 086/2007	Toufeeqah Ismail vs Yusuf Ismail Nasifa Ismail & Era Sun Properties Jones J Interdict – right of a second wife in an Islamic marriage to interdict her husband and his first wife from selling her home in respect of which she has an unregistered 99 year lease – interdict granted. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/02/2007	ECJ: 085/2007	Lungiswa Snowy Kambule vs The Master of the High Court & 7 others Pickering J Central to this application is the issue as to whether or not applicant and the late Burton Baduza were parties to a valid customary law marriage. Before turning to deal with this issue it is necessary to set out the history to the matter. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
05/02/2007	R: CA280/2006 ECJ: 103/2007	Eric Rowland Naude vs Daniel Joubert Plasket J, Ebrahim J Lease – Whether a lease agreement entered into between the appellant and the respondent had been cancelled by agreement. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
01/02/2007	R: CA&R 13/06 ECJ: 101/2007	Ayanda Mkase, Ayanda Tizane & Siyabonga Skosana vs The State Plasket J Appeal from the judgment of a Regional Court Magistrate, Port Elizabeth, in which the appellants were convicted of robbery with aggravating circumstances, kidnapping and escaping from lawful custody. In addition, the third appellant was convicted of the unlawful possession of a firearm. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
25/01/2007	R: 1176/04 ECJ: 081/2007	Vuyani Daluxolo Mabandla vs Eastern Cape Rural Finance Corporation Limited Dambuza J Rescission of Judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
25/01/2007	R: CA&R159/2006 ECJ: 72/2007	Mnene Zuko v The State Jansen J & Plasket J Criminal Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
2006	Back to Top
14/12/2006	R: 1837/05 ECJ:	Georg Schmidt Primary School vs The Member of the Executive Council The Department of Education, Eastern Cape Province Sangoni J Amendment of application to reflect that the Respondents restore the Applicant’s status as a school offering grades 1 – 7 and more particularly, to reinstate the Applicant’s curriculum entitlement to grades 6 and 7 with immediate effect. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
12/12/2006	R: 1071/05 ECJ: 74/2006	Nozintombi Felicia Mtshwane obo Akha Mtshwane vs The Road Accident Fund Dambuza J Claim for damages arising from a motor vehicle collision. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
12/12/2006	R: EL 472/03 ECD: 872/03 ECJ: 073/06	Petrus Johannes van Staden obo Bruno Shelve van Staden vs Road Accident Fund Dambuza J Claim for damages arising from a motor vehicle collision. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
12/12/2006	R:1089/03 ECJ:	SA National Parks vs Philip Weyer-Henderson & 2 others RJW Jones Action for ejectment – registered servitudal rights to graze and water stock following construction of a dam – description of servitude in a deed of submission to arbitration and the arbitration award – interpretation and extent of the servitude – whether servitude subsequently lost as a result of the decision of the Water Court ordering compensation for loss grazing when the height of dam wall was subsequently increased – whether in any event servitude acquired by prescription. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/12/2006	R: EL 487/05	Mncedi Hope Xabanisa vs The Road Accident Fund Sangoni J Action for Damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/12/2006	R: 701/04	Elliot Patric Nomala vs The Road Accident Fund Sangoni J Action for Damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/12/2006	R: 329/03 ECJ: 090/2006	Craig Richard Lindhorst & 3 others v Mark Gregory Andersen & 3 others Leach J Action for specific performance in regard to delivery of land shares. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/12/2006	R: 329/03 ECJ: 088/2006	Craig Richard Lindhorst & 3 others v Mark Gregory Andersen& 3 others Leach J Action for specific performance in regard to delivery of the shares. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/12/2006	R: CA 189/2006 ECJ: 061/2006	The Minister of Safety & Security vs Robin Glisson Jones J & Pickering Leave to appeal - police powers of arrest without warrant in terms of s 40(1)(a) of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 - peace officer authorised to arrest any person who commits or attempts to commit an offence in his presence - illegality of arrest determined in accordance with the way in which the statute has been interpreted, understood, and applied for many generations Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
06/12/2006	R: 62/06 ECJ: 72/2006	Member of Executive Council for Welfare vs Deliwe Muriel Njongi Leach J Applicant’s social grant invalidly terminate but subsequently restored – applicant, after a delay of more than 3 years, bringing a review to recover the amount she was not paid after her grant was stopped and before it was reinstated – monetary claim held to have prescribed – review should therefore not be entertained as brought solely to recover the amount due and is, in the circumstances, purely academic. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
04/12/2006	R: 1251/06 ECJ: 082/2006	Lithalelanga Marsharian Giyose vs The Member of the Executive Council for the Department of Roads and Transport Province of the Eastern Cape & 2 Others Dambuza J Declaratory Order Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
04/12/2006	R: 1708/05 ECJ : 062/2006	Albertus Beyleveld vs Muhamed Ismael Patel N.O. & 2 Others Jones J Trial procedure – witnesses – where the defendant serves a subpoena on the plaintiff’s counsel to give evidence against his own client in circumstances where there is no sound reason to believe that that counsel will be able to give admissible evidence which will advance the defendant’s case, the most probable inference is that the service of the subpoena is an abuse of the process of the court which could justify a punitive order for costs on the scale as between attorney and client, and, where he litigates in a representative capacity, de bonis propriis – the subpoena was set aside and a punitive costs order was made. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
04/12/2006	R: 62/2005	Ntsikane Z Mtshabe v The State Chetty J Attorney - conviction for fraud Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
04/12/2006	R: 1241/06 ECJ: 063/2006	Nthabiseng Gladys Mabehtu vs The Member of the Executive Council of the Eastern Cape Government Jones J Judicial review - an application for a disability grant having been dismissed, the applicant appealed to the Minister and, on appeal, was given a temporary disability grant but not a permanent grant - the applicant alleged a statutory entitlement to a permanent disability grant - her application was granted for a review of the decision on appeal. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
21/11/2006	R: 2743/06 ECJ: 077/2006	Worthy Homes cc & Another vs Firstrand Bank Limited & 2 Others Dambuza J Leave to appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
17/11/2006	R: 2716/2006 ECJ: 066/2006	Francios Roux Attorneys v Nqaga Ntswahlana & Elmarie De Klerk Jones J Compulsory sequestration - disputes of fact - no reason to believe that sequestration will be to the advantage of creditors - application dismissed Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
16/11/2006	R: CC53/06 ECJ: 065/2006	The State vs Themba Njokweni Jones J The accused was convicted in the regional court of the rape of a 5 year old child. In terms of section 53(1)(b) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 105 of 1997 the magistrate committed him to the high court for sentence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
15/11/2006	R: CC75/2005 ECJ	The State vs Luzuko Banisi & Others Dhlodhlo J Judgment - Murder, Robbery with aggravating circumstances as defined in section 1(1)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
15/11/2006	R: CA & R263/06 ECJ: 53/2006	Bonakele Gontsini vs The State Plasket J Appeal against sentence. The appellant had been convicted of assault with intent to commit grievous bodily harm and sentenced to 12 months imprisonment. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
09/11/2006	R: 11049/05 ECJ: 068/2006	*Merydale Propertyies (Pty) Ltd vs St Frances Field Investment (Pty) Ltd 1st Intervening Party:* Jean Finn Trust 2nd Intervening Party: Halifax Group (Pty) Ltd** Jones J Provisional winding up - inability to pay debts - debt disputed on reasonable grounds - application dismissed - provisional winding up order also sought on grounds that it was just and equitable by reason of a deadlock - no abuse of process - application granted - counter application in terms of section 252 of the Companies Act 61 of 1973 for sale of shares postponed pending return date of the provisional order. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
09/11/2006	R: 1223/2004 ECJ:	Dean De Villiers vs Edna De Villiers Jones J A court which is not sitting as a court of appeal or review has no general power to make a special costs order which is at variance with the costs order which had already been made. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
09/11/2006	R: 1249/2006 ECJ: 048/2006	Nicolene Parker & Henry Stephen Parker vs Trudy van Zyl, Gary Bellardi, Brett Chapple & Kerry Chapple Grogan A.J Dispute between parties, on who should exercise custody over an infant, pending the outcome of adoption proceedings, which have now been finalised. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/11/2006	R: 221/2006 ECJ: 139/2006 Case No: 62/2006	The State vs Jan Fredericks & Another Dambuza J & Mhlantla J Review Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
03/11/2006	R: 50/2006 ECJ: CA151/2006	ABSA Bank Limited v TI Vermaak Trust & Others Plasket J The respondent was sued in the court below in respect of an unlimited suretyship in respect of moneys lent to a business trust run by his late son Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Documents Microsoft Word Document
02/11/2006	R: 2903/06 ECJ: 078/2006	Walker Murray Alexander & 9 Others vs Halley Catherine Goodall Dambuza J Interdict & Restraining Order Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
31/10/2006	R: 2189/05 ECJ: 080/2006	Peter Bruce Wylie vs Johannes Petrus Daniel Botha NO & 8 Others Dambuza J Declaratory Order Adobe Acrobat (ptf) Document Microsoft Word Document
31/10/2006	R: 1475/04 ECJ: 046/2006	Johan Thysse vs Phillip Roedolf Bekker Jones J Actio de pauperie - dog bite - dog held to have acted contra naturam sui generis. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
27/10/2006	R: CA 189/2006 ECJ: 045/2006	The Minister of Safety and Security vs Robin Glisson Jones J & Pickering J Appeal - award of damages for wrongful arrest - arrest without warrant in terms of section 40 (1)(a) of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 - the alleged justification was that the person arrested had committed the offence of being drunk and disorderly in a street or road in the presence of the arresting officer - the trial court's finding was upheld that the onus of proving justification was not discharged because the arrest was not made in his presence within the meaning of the section - appeal dismissed. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
26/10/2006	R: 1856/06 ECJ: 134/2006	Anthony Johnson vs Mr Van Zyl NO & The National Director of Public Prosecution Dambuza J & Somyalo J The applicant was charged with and convicted of dealing in 25 kilograms of dagga valued at R25 000.00 under the Drugs and Drug Trafficking Act, Act No 140 of 1992. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
26/10/2006	R: 535/2005 ECJ:	The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited vs The Master of the High Court (Eastern Cape Division) & Others Plasket J & Liebenberg J The second and fifth respondents apply for leave to appeal against our order to the effect that their ‘challenge to the locus standi of the applicant is dismissed with costs. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
26/10/2006	R: 2754/2006 ECJ: 049/2006	BS Nkola & Bushbucks Football Club (Pty) Ltd vs The Joint Provisional Liquidators & others Grogan A.J. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/10/2006	R: CA341/05 ECJ:	Peter John France N.O & 1 Other vs Omni Technologies (Pty) Ltd t/a Gestetner Jones J, Jansen J & Goosen J Appeal – whether the onus was discharged of proof of an oral agreement, breach of the terms of which gave rise to the claim for damages – whether the loss and the quantum of the damages were properly proved – no basis on appeal for departing from the trial court’s findings of fact. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/10/2006	R: CA189/2006 ECJ: 045/2006	The Minister of Safety and Security vs Robin Glisson Jones J & Pickering Appeal - Award of damages for wrongful arrest - arrest without warrant in terms of section 40(1)(a) of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/10/2006	R: 1125/05 ECJ: 079/2006	Selwyn Robert Tromp vs Road Accident Fund Dambuza J Action for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
17/10/2006	R: 2764/2006 ECJ: 040/2006	Yusuf Meyer vs The State Pickering J.D. Appeal - The appellant was convicted by the regional magistrate, Port Elizabeth, of murder and sentenced. He appeals now against both conviction and sentence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
13/10/2006	R: 2764/2006 ECJ: 039/2006	Yolanda Tshona vs The Principle, Victoria Girls High School and 3 Others Pickering J.D. This is an urgent application for setting aside of the expulsion of applicant from a school hostel Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
12/10/2006	R: 2384/2006 ECJ: 041/2006	Mathilda Nell vs Louis Andries Nell Pickering J.D. This is an application in terms of Rule 43 in which the applicant claims maintenance pendente lite for herself and for her minor daughter as well as a contribution towards her costs. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
28/09/2006	R: CA 197/05 ECJ:	Road Accident Fund vs Cornel Forbes Jones J, Schoeman J Appeal – costs in the magistrates’ courts – an award of party and party costs including counsel’s fees at three times the amount of the tariff is no incompetent – such an award was not made arbitrarily and was not an unwarranted interference with the taxing-master’s discretion. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
28/09/2006	R: CA & R 360/05 ECJ:	Annarine Stratford-Tuke vs The State Jones J; Goosen AJ Appeal on conviction and sentence – attempted murder – on the facts the inference of intention to kill was properly drawn – sentence – over-emphasis on the serious nature of the offence – in the circumstances the magistrate’s failure to consider properly recommendations for the imposition of correctional supervision amounts to a misdirection on sentence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
12/09/2006	R: 2743/06 ECJ:076/2006	Worthy Homes cc & Another vs Firstrand Bank Limited & 2 Others Dambuza J This is an application for interim relief to have funds currently held by the first respondent on second respondent’s behalf held in trust, pending registration of transfer of a property in second respondent’s name, alternatively, cancellation of an agreement of sale between applicants and second respondent and outcome of a claim which applicants may institute against the second respondent for damages. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
07/09/2006	R: 603/2005 ECJ: 042/2006	POPCRU vs Minister of Correctional Services and 5 Others Plasket C Application to review - application for leave to appeal brought by the said respondents against a judgment given against them on 12 January 2006. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
04/09/2006	R: 2295/06 ECJ: 040/2006	Sturu Pasiya vs Andrew Stuart Paterson NO and 5 Others Plasket C This is an urgent application in which the applicant has applied for an interim interdict to prevent the sale by tender of Bush Bucks Football Club by the liquidators of Trendmania 4 (Pty) Ltd. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
31/08/2006	R: 103/05 ECJ: 083/2006	Pumla Ethel Manengela vs The Member of the Executive Council, Department of Education, Eastern Cape Province Dambuza J Judicial Review Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
29/08/2006	R: 19/02 ECJ: 084/2006	Zwelumntu Morris Vena vs Road Accident Fund Dambuza J Action for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
21/08/2006	R: 1638/2006	Douglas Rory Swanepoel & Another vs JT & T Agencies and Maintenance cc Ebrahim J This application was brought as a matter of urgency by the first and second applicants, who act in their representative capacities as the trustees of D J G J Property Trust Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
17/08/2006	R: 1584/06 ECJ: 138/2006	Rashaad Soomar vs The Honourable Mr Justice Kroon & 2 Others Dambuza J Application for judicial review Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
31/07/2006	R: ECJ: CA166/06	Johannes Jakobus Mallison vs Die Staat Froneman J.C. Appeal - The Appellant was found guilty on the charge of rape and was sentenced to lifelong imprisonment. He appeals now against both conviction and sentence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
27/07/2006	R: 1453/04 ECJ: 043/2006	Nelson Balekile Kiva vs The Minister of Correctional Service and 1 Other Plasket C Administrative Law - duty to furnish reasons for administrative action in terms of s5 of the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000 (the PAJA). Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
27/07/2006	R: 535/2005 ECJ: 041/2006	Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd vs The Master of the High Court and 4 Others Liebenberg J and Plasket J Review Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
26/07/2006	R: 62/05	Ntsikane Z Mthabe v The State Chetty J Fraud - Misappropriation Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
25/07/2006	R: 2020/03 ECJ: 047/2006	Dawson Frederick Ferreira N.O. vs The Road Accident Fund Jones J Costs - two counsel - discretion exercised to award the costs of two counsel by reason of the nature of the issues, the extent of the injuries, the large amount of compensation involved and the importance of the issues to the parties Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/06/2006	R: 100/2002 ECJ: 044/2006	Lungile Mgade vs The State Jones J, Pakade & Sangoni Appeal on conviction and sentence - murder - inferences - of wrongfulness and intent - so called aberratio ictus - intent in the form of dolus eventualis established. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/06/2006	R: 257/03 ECJ: 135/2006	The National Director of Public Prosecution vs Cornelius Petrus Schmitt & 6 Others Dambuza J Leave to appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/06/2006	R: 3815/04 ECJ: 133/2006	Atomic Transport cc t/a Freight V Transnet Limited Dambuza J In this case plaintiff claims an amount of money from the defendant for services rendered by plaintiff for or on defendant’s behalf. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
01/06/2006	R: 1220/2003 ECJ: 52/2006	Sharon Bosch v The Road Accident Fund Plasket J Action for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
01/06/2006	R: 749/04 ECJ: 137/2006	Minister of Safety & Security vs Tersia Telana Roux Moss Dambuza J Leave to appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
01/06/2006	R: 1253/05 ECJ: 074/2006	Zandile Singqandu vs Meeg Bank & 3 Others Dambuza J Condonation of non-compliance with rules of Court relating to form, service and time limits for the hearing of this application. Applicant was allowed to proceed by way of urgency in terms of Rule 6(12) of the Rules of Court. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
18/05/2006	R:892/03 ECJ: 57/2006	Hermanus van den Berg v The Road Accident Fund Plasket J Action for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
18/05/2006	R: 20060325 ECJ: 54/2006	The State v Bryce Webster Plasket J Review judgment: The accused pleaded guilty in the East London Magistrate’s Court to a charge of unlawful possession of unlawful narcotics, a contravention of s 4(b) of the Drugs and Drug Trafficking Act 140 of 1992. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
15/05/2006	R: CA & R75/06 ECJ: 55/2006	Mncedi Dayimani v The State Plasket J The appellant was convicted in the Regional Court, East London, of having raped the complainant. He was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment. He appeals against his conviction only. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
09/05/2006	R: 1764/05 ECJ:	Offit Enterprises (Pty) Ltd & Another vs The Premier of the Eastern Cape Government & Others Ebrahim J Application for leave to appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
25/04/2006	R: 2180/2004 ECJ: 031/2006	Thozamile Eric Magidimisi N.O vs The Premier of the Eastern Cape & Others Froneman J Constitutional and statutory duty of provincial government functionaries to ensure payment of court orders made against the province - competent and obliged to pay such orders from Provincial Revenue Fund under section 3 of State Liability Act 20 of 1957. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/04/2006	R: 745/05 ECJ: 136/2006	Jacques Pienaar & Ravin Gooranah vs The Magistrate (Mr J Burger, Esquire) Zwelitsha & The State Dambuza J Judgment: Whether a permanent stay of the criminal proceedings together with an attendant costs order should be granted. Adobe Acrobat (ptf) Document Microsoft Word Document
13/04/2006	R: 368/2004 ECJ: 024/2006	Ignatius Petrus Du Preez vs The Minister of Justice & Constitutional Developement & 3 others Erasmus J Complaint of the promotion of equality and prevention of unfair discrimination Act 4 of 2000. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
31/03/2006	R: 11483 ECJ: 030/2006	C H Parsons vs SARS Jansen J Appeal - against the Commissioner's revised assessment in respect of the appellant's 2000/2001 tax period. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
17/03/2006	R: 22/2005 ECJ: 028/2006	The Commissioner, South African Revenue Services vs May Garments & 5 others Erasmus J Application on motion - Section 354 of Companies Act 61 of 1973 - Application refused on facts. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
16/03/2006	R: EL 309/01	Pula Mvula Matshikwe vs The Road Accident Fund Ebrahim J Action for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
08/03/2006	CC: 1/2006 (P.E.) ECJ: 025/2006	The State vs Thembinkosi Hena & Mfundo Ngaphi Plasket J The two accused were charged with two counts of rape and with robbery with aggravating circumstances. The central issue is whether the state has proved beyond reasonable doubt that the accused were two of the three men who robbed and raped the complainants. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
27/02/2006	CA: 136/05 ECJ: 027/2006	Lynne Ann Van Wyk (born Mouton) and Gerrit Christian Van Wyk Jones J Divorce - maintenance - whether plaintiff wife entitled to permanent maintenance, ammount of maintenance - factors to be taken into account. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
21/02/2006	R: 1342/03 ECJ:	Raymond Dyssel vs The Road Accident Fund Ebrahim J Action for Damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
31/01/2006	R:1764/05 ECJ:	Offit Enterprises (PTY) Ltd & Another vs The Premier of the Eastern Cape Government & Others Ebrahim J In a Notice of Intended Expropriation, signed by the first respondent, the applicants were informed that the first respondent intended expropriating the properties for the purpose of transferring same to the second respondent, Coega Development Corporation (Pty) Ltd (‘CDC’). Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
24/01/2006	EL: 322/2003 ECD 719/03(a)	Xoliswa Norah Radasi and The State Jones J Motor collision - proof of negligence - an inference of negligence cannot be drawn from a reconstruction of the collision unless the interference is consistent with all know facts and unless it is the most probable inference form the known facts. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/01/2006	200501548 ECJ: 003/2006	The State and Andrew Alexander Plasket J Review Judgement - The conviction is in order but the sentence has been slightly amended. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/01/2006	200600001 ECJ: 004/2006	The State and Zongile Gumenge Plasket J Having convicted the accused of two counts of housebreaking with intent to steal and theft and assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm the magistrate sentenced the accused to four years imprisonment. Realising he had exceeded his sentencing jurisdiction the magistrate requested the case to be remitted. The sentence is set aside and the matter is remitted to the trial court for sentence to be imposed afresh. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
03/01/2006	Review No: 200501538	The State v Nico Potgieter Plasket J The accused was convicted in the Magistrate’s Court, Humansdorp of assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm. The magistrate referred the matter to the Regional Court for sentence. As the Regional Court magistrate had his doubts as to the propriety of the conviction, he referred the matter to the High Court on review. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
03/01/2006	R: 2005011207 ECJ: 56/2006	The State v Thembile Jaza Plasket J The accused was convicted of contempt of court in the statutory form that this offence takes in s 108(1) of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 32 of 1944. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
2005	Back to Top
09/12/2005	R: 10861/2005 ECJ: 026/2006	Titi Gladys Mahala vs Nolili Nkombombini & 1 other Erasmus J Right to arrange burial of deceased. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
05/12/2005	CA: 3908/2005 ECJ: 029/2006	Marr vs MEC for Health, EC and other Matthee AJ In this matter the issue is whether the respondant is in contempt of court and whether the respondant should be ordered to pay costs de bonis propriis. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
01/12/2005	CA: 603/05	Police & Prisoners Civil Rights Union & 75 Others and Minister of Correctional Services & 5 others Plasket J Application to review and set aside the dismissal of the second to seventy sixth applicants - decision to dismiss was felt to be tainted by infringements. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
29/11/2005	R: 2991/05 ECJ: 002/2006	Hendrick Johannes Engelbrecht and Merry Hill (Propriatary) Limited & 3 others Plasket J Purpose of section is to provide reasonable protection to a purchaser of land, re-stated, as was the peremptory nature of the notice envisaged therein. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
11/11/2005	R: 563/2005 ECJ: 071/2005	Eric Dondashe t/a Dondashe Business Trust vs Metcash Trading Ltd t/a Metro Cash and Carry Plasket J Application for the rescission of a judgment granted by default against the applicant - Requirements for rescission set out - Applicant failing to establish good cause for rescission - Application dismissed with costs. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
10/11/2005	R: 20050471 ECJ: 070/2005	The State vs Bulelani Khohlakala Plasket C and Leach L.E. Accused erroneously charged with and convicted of escaping from custody in contravention of s 51(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 when the evidence established that he was already in custody in a prison at the time of his escape. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
21/10/2005	R: 050293 ECJ: 078/2005	Monde Michael Johnson and The State Jones and Kroon JJ Sentence - driving under the influence of liquor - 12 months correctional supervision plus 12 months imprisonment fully suspended for 4 years excessively severe in the circumstances - sentence reduced accordingly. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
20/10/2005	CA: 364/2005 ECJ: 010/2005	Kirsten Carla Burchell (Birkholtz) and Barry Grant Burchell Froneman J Contempt of court for non-compliance with court orders. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
19/10/2005	CC: 79/05 ECJ: 079/2005	Hendik Motaung v The State Jones J Compulsory minimum sentence - referral to the High Court for sentence for rape - evidence against accused given through intermediary. Substantial and compelling circumstances for the imposition of a lesser sentence than life imprisonment found to be present. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
27/09/2005	CA&R: 323/05 ECJ: 076/2005	Mziwethu Mpulampula and The State Jones J Bail appeal - robbery involving the taking of a vehicle and the use of a firearm. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
27/09/2005	CA: 1535/05 ECJ: 077/2005	Z Ndzaba and Minister of Safety & 2 others Jones J In the absence of special directions in the will, an heir is the person entitled to decide upon the funeral and burial arrangements for the deceased's body. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
23/09/2005	R: CC 81/05	The State vs Nomathamsanqa Cynthia Kwaza & Others Ebrahim J Criminal Judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
22/09/2005	CA: 1281/04 ECJ: 075/2005	MEC for Social Development and Deliwe Njongi Jones J Application for leave to appeal - whether defence of prescription has prospects of success - leave to appeal granted. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
24/08/2005	CA: 483/04	Michael John Bilsbury and The Standard Bank Jones J and Pickering JJ Discharge of suretyship obligation Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document (59.3 Kb) Microsoft Word Document (49.0 Kb)
19/08/2005	CA: 587/04 ECJ: 071/2005	Gary Strydom and Scania SA & Phillip Lategan Jones J and Sandi JJ Motor Collision between two vehicles - Negligence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document (65.2 Kb) Microsoft Word Document (53.0 Kb)
17/08/2005	178/05 ECJ: 065/2005	Cooper Conroy Bell & Richards and Michael Allan Flynn Froneman J Appeal against a judgement Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (44.9Kb) Microsoft Word Document (49.5Kb)
16/08/2005	CA&R: 213/05 ECJ: 070/2005	The State and M Dyantyi Jones J and Sandi JJ Trespass attempt Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document (63.4 Kb) Microsoft Word Document (51 Kb)
11/08/2005	191/2004 ECJ: 066/2005	Danmist Properties cc and Great Kei Municipality Froneman J Contest of Sale of Property Transaction Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (51.0 Kb) Microsoft Word Document (21.2 Kb)
26/06/2005	CA 272 04 ECJ: 072/2005	Colin Urquhart and Compensation Commissioner Jones J and Erasmus JJ Compensation for Occupational injuries Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (121Kb) Microsoft Word Document (87.0Kb)
24/06/2005	20050169 ECJ: 053/2005	The State v Xolani Nabo Pickering J, Plasket J Fraud charges Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (10.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document (35.0Kb)
23/06/2005	20050529 ECJ: 059/2005	State v Lusu Froneman and Plasket JJ Right to a fair trial Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document) (54.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (54.0Kb)
21/06/2005	20050401 ECJ: 057/2005	State v Hlalatu Froneman and Plasket JJ Conviction for contravening s 17 of the Domestic Violence Act 116 of 1998 Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (45.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document (46.0Kb)
03/06/2005	CA 410/04 ECJ: 052/2005	Thandeka Vivian Honi v The Road Accident Fund Liebenberg, Froneman and Plasket JJ Claim for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (76.3Kb) Microsoft Word Document (70.5Kb)
31/05/2005	CA 59/04 ECJ: 074/2005	Portia Mindi vs Tembeka Malgas Liebenberg and Plasket JJ Appeal against an order directing the appellant to pay the respondent R28 882.60 plus costs. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document Microsoft Word Document
26/05/2005	550/05 ECJ: 062/2005	Van Aardt v Van Aardt and Others Plasket J Application to interdict the sale of immovable property Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (75.7KB) Microsoft Word Document (73.5Kb)
20/05/2005	616/2004 ECJ: 043/2005	Andries Froncois Marais N.O. vs Zoo Net Trading CC, t/a Durr Estates and Reginald Tobias Marais and 2 others Froneman J, Norman AJ Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (61.6Kb) Microrsoft Word document (61.0Kb)
19/05/2005	1281/04	Deliwe Muriel Njongi v Member of the Executive Council for Social Development, Eastern Cape Province Jones J Termination or suspension of a grant followed by its re-instatement - judicial review of termination or suspension appropriate in the circumstances - condonation of delay granted - order made for payment of the amount of the grant which should have been made during termination or suspension, with interest. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (67.2Kb) Microsoft Word Document (56.5Kb)
19/05/2005	1911/03 ECJ: 049/2005	Vuyiswa Gladys Nkebana v Member of the Executive Council for Social Development, Eastern Cape Province Jones J Application for social grant Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (52.6Kb) Microsoft Word Document (47.0Kb)
19/05/2005	2135/05	Bonakele Themba N.O v Member of the Executive Council for Social Development, Eastern Cape Province Jones J Application by the representative of the deceased estate for access to information for purposes of a possible review of the delay in approving a social grant. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (40.3Kb) Microsoft Word Document (42.0Kb)
19/05/2005	165/05 ECJ: 044/2005	Thozamile Mbetshu vs SABC + 2 Jones J Application for re-instatement of an employee on the ground that his dismissal was not constitutional. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (63.1Kb) Microsoft Word document (56.5Kb)
16/05/2005	631/2004 ECJ: 042/2005	Legal Aid Board and Otto Swart Froneman & Chetty JJ, Norman AJ Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (43.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (47.0Kb)
13/05/2005	CA 481/04 ECJ: 040/2005	Fedgas (Pty) vs Gary P Herbst & Pierrie J du Preez Jones & Hancke JJ Deed of suretyship - validity of - principal debtor not identified in the written document suretyship invalid application for amendmend to particulars of claim to claim rectification dismissed. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (53.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document (50.0Kb)
12/05/2005	EL 201/05 ECD 681/05 ECJ: 041/2005	Hotel Reservations Worldwide (Pty) Ltd vs Natalie Corinne Ristow Kat Leisure (Pty) Ltd Chetty JJ Application for final interdict Restraint of Trade Clause in Letter of appointment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (66.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (56.0Kb)
10/06/2005	CA 539/04 ECJ: 054/2005	CME Sales & Services v Transtruct Pty Ltd Jones J & Dambuza AJ Engineering contract - liability to pay sub-contractor - contract between contractor and sub-contractor proved in respect of additional work - main contractor liable to the subcontractor in respect thereof. Adobe acrobat (pdf) document (74.9Kb) Microsoft Word document (63.5Kb)
09/06/2005	841/2004	Capricorn Makelaars (EDMS) BPK & 3 other v EB Shelf Investment No 79 (Pty) LTD & 3 others Froneman J A party seeking early discovery under rule 35(14) must show that the discovery is 'reasonably necessarry in the circumstances' (connoting a special advantage or element of need, but not 'necessity' or 'dire necessity') for the purposes of pleading, in addition to the specificity of documents and relevance to reasonably anticipated issues in the action required by the rule. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (54.7Kb) Microsoft Word document (54.5Kb)
16/05/2005	CA 631/04 ECJ: 009/2006	Legal Aid Board and Otto Swart Froneman J, Chetty J and Norman AJ Appeal - respondent’s failure in his dealings with the appellant to disclose his interest in an entity known as Tornado Tracers. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document Microsoft Word document
6/05/2005	847/2004 ECJ: 036/2005	Sikutshwa v Member of The Executive Council for Social Development, Eastern Cape Province and Others Goosen AJ Administrative Action - duty to furnish reasons in terms of section 5(2) of PAJA Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (143Kb) Microsoft Word Document (108Kb)
3/05/2005	1258/04 ECJ: 035/2005	Carel Lodewyk Otto vs Patrys Farming Jones J Exception – whether fraudulent non-disclosure is properly alleged – whether duty to disclose is properly alleged – whether inducement to contract is properly alleged - whether the pleading is excipiable because the allegations of fraud are in conflict with the terms of the contract induced by the fraud Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (56.6Kb) Microsoft Word Document (49.0Kb)
29/04/2005	CA 334/2000 ECJ: 037/2005	Frederick Albertus Snyman vs Road Accident Fund Jennett & Jones JJ Motor accident - proof of negligence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (77.7Kb) Microsoft Word Document (57.5Kb)
29/04/2005	CA 433/2004 ECJ: 055/2005	Baron Camilo Agasim-Pereira of Fulwood Pickering and Plasket JJ Judgement against appellant Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (84.5Kb) Microsoft Word Document (97.5Kb)
28/04/2005	1749/2003& 1507/03 ECJ: 047/2005	CDA Boedery (EDMS) BPK & ander v Nelson Mandela Metropolitaanse Munisipaliteit & 4 Ander Froneman J Munisipale eiendomsbelasting en tussentydse grondwaardasies van landelike eiendomme wat vir landboudoeleindes gebruik word, nie ongrondwetlik of ongeldig weens botsing met art 229 van die Grondwet of nie-voldoening aan waardasie-ordonnansie nie. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (93.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (130Kb)
6/04/2005	2733/96 EC J: 045/2005	Selby Sonwabile Nonxago and The Multilateral Motor vehicle Accidents Fund Kroon J Action for damages for bodily injuries sustained in motor accident Adobe Acrobat (pdf) doucment (134Kb) Microsoft Word Document (103Kb)
31/03/2005	069/2005 ECJ: 069/2005	LL Castelyn, BE Castelyn, LL Castelyn and T Lamont, PI van Rooyen, Registrar of Deeds Cape Town Sandi J Sale of Land to be in Writing Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document (55.1 Kb) Microsoft Word Document (52.5 Kb)
31/03/2005	125/05 ECJ: 023/2005	Van Eyk v Minister of Correctional Services & Others Jones J Review of a decision of a disciplinary inquiry not to dismiss disciplinary proceedings on grounds of delay. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (72.2Kb) Microsoft Word Document (73.5Kb)
30/03/2005	169/99	Johann Folscher Potgieter and Ilse Potgieter Chetty D Divorce - custody and maintenance Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (84.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document (61.0Kb)
24/03/2005	143/2005 ECJ: 019/2005	Ortlieb & Associates vs Camdeboo Local Municipal Council + 6 Pickering J Review of decision by municipal council Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (54.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document (76.0Kb)
24/03/2005	178/2004 ECJ: 046/2005	Wildlife and Environment Society of South Africa and MEC for Economic Affairs, Environment and Tourism, Eastern Cape Provincial Government Director: Environmental Affairs in The Department for Economic Affairs, Environment and Tourism, Eastern Cape Provincial Government Cape Produce CO (Pty) Ltd t/a Pelts Products C & M Consulting Engineers Pickering J Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (130Kb) Microsoft Word Document (122Kb)
24/03/2005	512/04 ECJ: 028/2005	Nomasani Kulati vs MEC for Social Development Eastern Cape Jones J Application for a social grant Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (70.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (61.5Kb)
22/03/2005	1170/05; 1171/05 1132/05; 1133/05 1169/05 ECJ: 039/2005	The National Director of Public Prosecutions Jones J Applications for a preservation order of motor vehicles in terms of Chapter 6 (section 38) of the Prevention of Organized Crime Act 121 of 1998 Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (69.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (57.0Kb)
18/03/2005	CA 517/2004 ECJ: 024/2005	CM Berriman vs Road Accident Fund Jones J & Dambuza AJ Motor Collision - proof of negligence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (60.2Kb) Microsoft Word Document (50.0Kb)
17/03/2005	1614/04(SECLD) ECJ: 018/2005	Dr Frederick Claassen + 1 v Alistair Rudman Jansen J Contempt of court Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (56.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document (72.5Kb)
17/03/2005	1073/2001 ECJ: 021/2005	Technofin Leasing & Finance (Pty) Ltd Pickering J Interpretation of s 60 of South African Schools Act 84 of 1996 - does not exclude State's liability for damage or loss caused contractually Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (56.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (77.0Kb)
17/03/2005	4037/2004	Deborah Gaynor Pughe-Parry vs Ainsley Owen Pughe-Parry Erasmus J Factual issue Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (39.5Kb) Microsoft Word Document (42.5Kb)

16/03/2005	CA&R 562/2004 ECJ: 020/2005	Tammy Lottering vs The State Chetty and Pillay JJ Conviction for theft, Appeal against sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (45.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document (38.5Kb)
15/03/2005	CA 382/2004 ECJ: 031/2005	Rodney Vivian Rudman vs The State Jones J, Piilay J & Dambuza AJ Appeal – indecent assault – substitution of a conviction of rape not appropriate on appeal – sufficiency or otherwise of evidence of indecent assaults – appropriate sentence for indecent assault Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (82.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (63.5Kb)
11/03/2005	CA 325/2004 ECJ: 014/2005	Kirtley v The Compensation Commisioner, The Minister of Labour Pickering & Chetty JJ Civil Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (71.2Kb) Microsoft Word Document (56.5Kb)
10/03/2005	1207/2004 ECJ: 067/2005	Dockside Panelbeaters and Don Pedro cc t/a Dockside Panelbeaters, Mrs Renika Rungan, Mr R.L Rungan Sandi J Opposing use of Trading Name Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document (121 Kb) Microsoft Word Document (103 Kb)
07/03/2005	CA 181/04 ECJ: 006/2006	Mbulezo Michael Mgobo and The State Froneman J Appeal - conviction for murder upon a plea of guilty. Sentence reduced. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document Microsoft Word Document
2/03/2005	CA & R: 704/2004 ECJ: 016/2005	Dante van Niekerk v The State Erasmus & Chetty JJ Criminal Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (77.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (97.5Kb)

28/02/2005	EL 362/02 ECJ: 013/2005	GriebvP&OGrindrod Logistics (Pty) Ltd & Barlow Handling Jones J Action for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (84.0Kb) Microsoft Word Document (61.5Kb)
25/02/2005	CA 422/2004 ECJ: 027/2005	L Nel cc t/a Doo-Littles vs Specialised Freight Services cc Jones J Appeal – contract – proof of the terms of the contract – claim for payment – proof of amount. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (78.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document (63.0Kb)
25/02/2005	660/2005 ECJ: 015/2005	De Lange v The Clerk of the Magistrate's Court, Port Elizabeth (1st respondent) The President of the Regional Court, Port Elizabeth (2nd respondent) The Minister of the Justice and Constitutional Development (3rd respondent) The Department of Correctional Services (4th respondent) Urgent application - Order regarding correctional institution where the applicant to serve sentence of imprisonment. Interim relief. Adobe Acrobat (pdf)) document (110Kb) Microsoft Word Document (80Kb)
24/02/2005	170/2005 ECJ: 017/2005	James Cooke Biggs, Trevor John Biggs, Johannes Petrus Daniel Botha and Jonannes M Muller, Shelfcorp 75 cc The Registrar of Deeds Leach J Tenant having a pre-emptive right to “match” an offer to purchase the leased property received by the owner Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (72.0Kb) Microsoft Word Document (85.5Kb)
24/02/2005	1632/04 ECJ: 029/2005	Jean Sylvia Hill & 3 others vs Deon Neville Trollip & 4 others Froneman J Eviction of respondents from certain property Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (45.4Kb) Microsoft Word Document (49.0Kb)
22/02/2005	CA & R 250/'04 ECJ: 010/2005	Veldman v The State Jones & Sandi JJ Appeal against the conviction and sentence is dismissed. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (62.3Kb) Microsoft Word Document (54.0Kb)
21/02/2005	CA 322/2004 ECJ: 002/2005	Bignals Tranport (Pty) Ltd v Catholic Diocese of Port Elizabeth Pickering, Liebenberg & Sandi JJ Action for damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (114Kb) Microsoft Word Document (113Kb)
21/02/2005	1937/01 ECJ: 006/2005	Sasfin Bank Limited v Hoerskool Cilliers Jansen J Action: Money owing Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (97.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (136Kb)
18/02/2005	650/04 ECJ: 061/2005	Roux v Road Accident Fund Plasket J Review of taxation Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (55.3Kb) Microsoft Word Document (52.0Kb)
18/02/2005	CA 174/2004 ECJ: 030/2005	Road Accident Fund v Nandipha Matshobeni Erasmus and Sandi JJ Damages - motor vehicle collission Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (81.5Kb) Microsoft Word Document (74.0Kb)
17/02/2005	2019/04 ECJ: 025/2005	Body Corporate of Sunninghill Park and Nobumba and Others Leach and Plasket JJ Review of decision by a magistrate to refuse to authorise a warrant of execution against immovable property, in terms of section (66(1)(a) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 32 of 1944 Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (77.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (68.5Kb)
17/02/2005	461/05 ECJ:001/2005	Raymond Dennis Ballinger + 1 and Norvic Diverse Systems cc t/a Johns Builders + 1 Jones J Proof of builder's lien justifying interference with owners right to possession of immovable property Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (69.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (55.5Kb)
14/02/2005	CA 314/2004 ECJ: 007/2005	Schmitt v The State Jansen, Nepgen & Sandi JJ Full bench appeal: Fraud, sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (92.0Kb) Microsoft Word Document (132Kb)
11/02/2005	328/04 ECJ: 026/2005	John Crozier & 1 Other vs Shaun Pretorius Froneman J Assault Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (33.7Kb) Microsoft Word Document (41.0Kb)
11/02/2005	CA 114/2004 ECJ: 003/2005	Lid van die Uitvoerende Raad vir die Department van Gesondheid vs Juanita Beling Jones & Pillay JJ Civil Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (60.3Kb) Microsoft Word Document (58.5Kb)
11/02/2005	CA 114/04	Dept van Gesondheid, Oos Kaap v J Beling Jones & Pillay JJ Civil Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (60.3Kb) Microsoft Word Document (58.5Kb)
03/02/2005	2130/2004 ECJ: 011/2005	Goldengate Delta v General Motors Plasket J Application for a postponement - Principles to be applied restated - No basis established for the court to exercise its discretion on favour of the applicant - Application for the postponement accordingly dismissed Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (54.6Kb) Microsoft Word Document (58.5Kb)
31/01/2005	33/2004 ECJ: 009/2005	Philippus George Slabbert and Frederik Johannes Jakobus Lotter Leach J Sale of immoveable property Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (62.4Kb) Microsoft Word Document (72.0Kb)
18/01/2005	3903/04 ECJ: 008/2005	Mnisi Sixaso and The MEC of Department of Welfare, Eastern Cape Province Leach J Application for review for a maintenance grant Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (53.2Kb) Microsoft Word Document (57.5Kb)
18/01/2005	3902/04 ECJ: 005/2005	Nongalise Nyumbana v MEC of Dept of Welfare, Eastern Cape Province Leach J Applicant seeking review of a alleged failure to process an application doe a maintenance grant under Act No 1992 lodged before such grants were abolished by Act No 106 of 1997 - Court consider the award of a maintenance grant after the abolition thereof - but in any event, applicant had failed to make out a case as it appeared that her maintenance grant had been approved but thereafter cancelled as it has not been collected. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (57.0Kb) Microsoft Word Document (72.0Kb)
18/01/2005	3900/04 ECJ: 004/2005	N B Mfubu v MEC of Dept of Welfare, Eastern Cape Province Leach J Application for assistance Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (59.2Kb) Microsoft Word Document (58.5Kb)
09/01/2005	CA: 3185/05 ECJ: 005/2006	First Base Construction vs Ukhahlamba District Municipality & 8 others Plasket J Award of tender by local Government Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document Microsoft Word Document
2004	Back to Top
10/12/2004	CA & R 844/0	Mdyogolo v The State Leach & Miller JJ The appalant,who was legally represented, was tried in the regional court on a charge of robbing with aggrevating circumstances. Convicted as charged, he was sentenced to 20 years imprisonment under the provisions of 151(2) (e) (i) of the Criminal Law Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (59.5Kb) Microsoft Word Document (58.5Kb)
08/12/2004	681/04 ECJ:055/2004	Securicor (SA) (Pty) Limited & Others v Lotter & Others Froneman J, Dambuza and Hole AJJ Whether restraint agreement of employees of old employer transferred to new employer when business is transferred as going concern in terms of s.197 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (75.8Kb) Microsoft Word Document 75.0Kb)
7/12/2004	3634/04, 3634/04, 3667/04	Ntame & Mnyaka v MEC, Welfare, Eastern Cape Plasket J Application for social assistance Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (125Kb) Microsoft Word Document (97.0Kb)
26/11/2004	CA&R 235/04 ECJ:047/2004	Yoleko v S Pickering and Leach JJ Criminal Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (37.1Kb) Microsoft Word document (31.5Kb)
26/11/2004	CA & R 550/04 ECJ:044/2004	Swartbooi v S Pickering, Leach JJ and Naude AJ Full Bench Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (71.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (52Kb)
25/11/2004	925/03	Reed & Others v The Master of the High Court & other Plasket J and Dambuza AJ Review of a decision of the Master to uphold an objection to a liquidation and distribution account Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (179Kb) Microsoft Word document (134Kb)
25/11/2004	477/04 ECJ:048/2004	Amatole District Municipality & Another v King William’s Town Taxi Management & 7 Others Plasket J Application for leave to appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (66.7Kb) Microsoft Word document (50.5Kb)
25/11/2004	CA&R 222/04 ECJ:045/2004	Sazi v S Pickering and Leach JJ Criminal Appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (29.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (29Kb)
25/11/2004	110/04; 826/04; 143/04; 2541/03 ECJ:050/2004	Vumazonke & Others v MEC for Social Development & Welfare for Eastern Cape Province Plasket J Application Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (29.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (29Kb)
25/11/2004	CA 47/2004 ECJ:043/2004	Nel v the Road Accident Fund Jones, Locke and Plasket JJ Appeal on fact – insufficient basis for interfering with trial court’s findings of credibility – insufficiency of evidence of negligence. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (65.3Kb) Microsoft Word document (49Kb)
16/11/2004	3439/2004	Marthinus Jacobus Janse van Vuuren and Andrew Frensch Boshoff, The Registrar of Deeds Lisa Natalie Boshoff & Andre Blom Sandi J the applicant seeks an interim interdict prohibiting the first, second and third respondents from alienating the property known as 16 Kromme River Estate to any person other than the applicant Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (62.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (64.5Kb)
16/11/2004	3655/2004 ECJ: 034/2005	Maurice Mangena and Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality - Mzimasi Leslie Mangcotywa Sandi J Suspension of applicant from his employment pending the outcomeof the investigation of allegations of misconduct against him. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (74.1Kb) Microsoft Word Document (72.0Kb)
10/11/2004	3551/2004 ECJ:049/2004	Sam v Edu-College Plasket J Application for Interdict Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (75.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (64Kb)
2/11/2004	1525/04 (P.E.)	Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality v Bhaxana + 4 and Various Others Jansen J Application - Eviction order Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (44.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (56.0Kb)
29/10/2004	3475/04 (P.E.) ECJ: 041/2004	W G Feeds v Cadbury (Pty) Ltd Jansen J Application - Contract Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (41.0Kb) Microsoft Word document (44.0Kb)
28/10/2004	2280/04 (P.E.) ECJ: 039/2004	Brittannia Trading Co. Ltd vs Amanzi Estate (Pty) Ltd + 2 Jansen J Summary Judgement Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (41.0Kb) Microsoft Word document (45.5Kb)
28/10/2004	1291/03 ECJ:051/2004	Maleka v the Health Professions Council of SA & Another Jones J Judicial review of the removal of an entry in the register kept by the Health Council – register in the category of independent practice (general practitioners) – whether the court of the situs of the register (TPD) has exclusive jurisdiction – whether correction of an entry made as a result of a computer error by removing the entry to the register in the category publick service (general practitioners), which confers a more restricted right to practice, is administrative action within the meeting of the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act No 3 of 2000. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (80.1Kb) Microsoft Word document (53Kb)
22/10/2004	1603/03 ECJ:053/2004	Matinese v MEC Dept of Welfare, Eastern Cape Province Leach J Disability grant-terminated without proper notice and without beneficiary being afforded a hearing -illegal termination set aside on review - beneficiary entitled to payment of amounts she would have received her grant had it not been terminated, together with interest thereon. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (78.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (80.5Kb)
21/10/2004	1601/03	Makalima v MEC for Health, EC & others Leach J Review applications brought against the Member of the Executive Council for what is now known as the Department of Social Development (formerly Department of Welfare) in the Eastern Cape Province arising from applicatoins foe Social grants. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (83.9Kb) Microsoft Word document (82.0Kb)
21/10/2004	CA&R 482/2004 ECJ:042/2004	Lindani v S Jones and Chetty JJ Sentence – declaration as habitual criminal - whether discretion properly exercised – analysis of previous convictions Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (49.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (32.5Kb)
20/10/2004	CA694/2003 ECJ:37/2004	Fourie v Land- en Landbou van Suid-Afrika Jansen J Jurisdiction Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (45.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (37Kb)
18/10/2004	CA694/03(GHT) ECJ:037/2004	P S Fourie and Land - EN Landbou van Suid -Afrika Jansen J Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (46.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (48.5Kb)
14/10/2004	1809/2004 ECJ: 032/2005	Aerosat cc and Independent Communication Authority of South Africa Sandi J Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (127Kb) Microsoft Word Document (122Kb)
21/9/2004	20040861 ECJ:21/2004	S v Dial Pickering and Plasket JJ Ascertainment of the age of an accused Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (55.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (46Kb)
09/9/2004	20040845 ECJ:26/2004	S v Nyumbeka and Mtshukwana Leach and Plasket JJ Conditions of suspension of sentence for assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (28.2Kb) Microsoft Word document (30Kb)
09/9/2004	200401068 ECJ:27/2004	S v Solomon Leach and Plasket JJ Charge brought under wrong act Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (31.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (30.5Kb)
09/9/2004	ECJ:22/2004 CA & R 201/04	Ebrahim v S Mhlantla and Plasket JJ Sentence for fraud Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (45.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (34.5Kb)
02/9/2004	878/2004 1376/2002 1377/2002 1523/2002 ECJ:24/2004	King and others v Attorneys Fidelity Fund Board of Control and the Minister of Justice Chetty J Stated case - determination in terms of Rule 33(6) Uniform Rules of Court - Constitutionality of ss 47(1)(g), (4), (5) and 47A of the Attorneys Act 53 of 1979. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (133Kb) Microsoft Word document (70.5Kb)
02/9/2004	ECJ:23/2004 17/03 18/03 19/03	Hosking and others v the Attorneys Fidelity Fund Board of Control Chetty J Exception and application in terms of Rule 30 of the Uniform Rules of Court Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (129Kb) Microsoft Word document (68.5Kb)
01/9/2004	CA and R 163/04 ECJ:36/2004	Tanatu v S Mhlantla and Plasket JJ Requirements for valid identification parade Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (96.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (69.5Kb)
01/9/2004	1907/03	Kate v The Member of the Executive council for the Department of Welfare, Eastern Cape Froneman J Social grants – review of failure to consider applications for disability grant – remedies of back pay and interest – to what extent SCA case of Jayiya v MEC Welfare, EC binding on Eastern Cape welfare cases. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (101Kb) Microsoft Word document (76 Kb)
01/9/2004	ECJ:20/2004 CA & R 554/04	S v Mako Plasket J and Pickering J Sentence - assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (67Kb) Microsoft Word document (49.5 Kb)
26/8/2004	CA & R 964/02 ECJ:19/2004	Toba and another v S Jennett MP, Jansen JCH and Pickering JD Remittal to trial court for further evidence – inadequate performance of legal representative alleged Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (109Kb) Microsoft Word document (78 Kb)
29/07/04 26/08/04	366/04 ECJ: 060/2005	Price v Van Zyl and Others Plasket J Exception - shareholders' agreement - whether such agreement creates fiduciary relationships between the parties to it. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (64.1Kb) Microsoft Word document (58.5Kb)
27/7/2004	ECD:1070/2002 EL: 401/2002 ECJ:2/2004	Hagemann and another v Road Accident Fund Plasket J Loss of earning capacity Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (52.7Kb) Microsoft Word document (41Kb)
08/7/2004	CA520/2003 ECJ:7/2004	Shoprite Checkers Lta t/a Megasave v Khan and the Sheriff of the High Court, Humansdorp Erasmus, Plasket JJ, Dambuza AJ Conditions of sales in execution Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (179Kb) Microsoft Word document (101Kb)
05/7/2004	CA 377/2001 ECJ:19/2004	Road Accident Fund v Oberholzer Nepgen J, Chetty J and Pillay AJ Damages for loss of earnings Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (124Kb) Microsoft Word document (77.5 Kb)
12/6/2004	376/98 ECJ:15/2004	Harris v Wheeldon Rushmere and Cole Erasmus J Review of taxation Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (59.1Kb) Microsoft Word document (42.5Kb)
10/6/2004	2003516 ECJ:25/2004	S v Ntame Froneman and Plasket JJ Review jurisdiction of High Court Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (34.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (30.5Kb)
9/06/2004	2733/96 EC J: 045/2005	Selby Sonwabile Nonxago and The Multilateral Motor vehicle Accidents Fund Kroon J Action for damages for bodily injuries sustained in motor accident Adobe Acrobat (pdf) doucment (134Kb) Microsoft Word Document (103Kb)
03/6/2004	499/2004 ECJ:3/2004	Osner v Osner Plasket J Preservation of asset pending divorce settlement Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (89.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (63Kb)
28/5/2004	CA&R 638/2003 ECJ:8/2004	Henning v S Pickering and Sandi JJ Crimen Injuria Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (66.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (46.5Kb)
03/5/2004	CC142/2003 ECJ:12/2004	S v Rodolo Sandi J Admission of hearsay evidence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (61Kb) Microsoft Word document (46.5Kb)
23/4/2004	CA 7/2003 ECJ:5/2004	Klerck N.O. v SA Metal and 8 others, Macsteel International Far East, Hefferman Erasmus , Chetty and Plasket JJ Escrow agreement Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (156Kb) Microsoft Word document (94.5Kb)
02/4/2004	1233/02 ECJ:9/2004	High Dune House (Pty) Ltd v Lester and Ndlambe Municipality Pickering J Property Rights Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (57.3Kb) Microsoft Word document (44Kb)
31/03/04	884/2004 ECJ: 069/2005	Lodewicus Castelyn v Tommy Lamont, Petrus Van Rooyen & Registrar of Deeds Cape Town Sandi J Sale of land must be in writing - Leaving of blank places on deed of sale - no description of the property on deed of sale - sale agreement declared null and void. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document Microsoft Word document
17,18/03/04	CA 1225/2002	Newton Glen Bouwer + 4 Tea & Coffee Distribution] Pickering J Unlawful Competition Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (125 Kb) Microsoft Word Document (92.0Kb)
17/3/2004	179/2003 ECJ:16/2004	The Head of Department of the Department of Health: Province E.C. & 2 others v Grahamstown Makana Private Hospital Jennett, Erasmus and Ebrahim JJ Review Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (65Kb) Microsoft Word document (43.5 Kb)
11/3/2004	20040275 ECJ:6/2004	S v Gotyana Pickering and Plasket JJ Sentence - Possession of Dagga Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (34.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (31.5 Kb)
09/03/04 06/05/04	612/03 ECJ: 056/2005	Colarossi v Gerber Plasket J Damages - quantum in respect of loss of income-earning capacity and general damages. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (132Kb) Microsoft Word document (105Kb)
03/3/2004	ECJ:1/2004 95/2004	Emmerson WD v Emmerson CL Plasket J Failure to pay maintenance, issue estoppel Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (40.2Kb) Microsoft Word document (32 Kb)
27/2/2004	CA 410/03 ECJ:14/2004	Falconer and another v Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality Erasmus, Pillay and Sandi JJ Interdict – Use of property contrary to Town Planning Regulations Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (59.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (43.5 Kb)
19/2/2004	CA 40/2003 CA 207/2003 ECJ:4/2004	S v Zuba and 23 similar cases Froneman, Leach and Plasket JJ Establishment of Reform School in Eastern School Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (61.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (45 Kb)
16/2/2004	1248/2002 ECJ:18/2004	WF Osner Investments (Pty) Ltd v Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality Erasmus J Servitude Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (41Kb) Microsoft Word document (33.5 Kb)
30/1/2004	CA786/03 ECJ:17/2004	van Lill N.O. and others v Marais and Cape Mohair & Wool (Pty) Ltd Ludorf, Erasmus and Plaskett JJ Restraint of trade Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (76.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (55.5 Kb)
2003	Back to Top
	186/01	Van der Spuy v Minister of Correctional Services Leach J Negligence -- remoteness of harm -- prison warders negligently allowing prisoners to escape -- during course of escape, prisoner intentionally shooting plaintiff, a member of the public who happened to be near the scene -- damage suffered by the plaintiff not too remote for Minister of Correctional Services to be held liable to the plaintiff. Costs -- merits decided as a separate issue at the outset -- declarator in favour of the plaintiff -- whether plaintiff should be awarded costs at that stage or whether costs should stand over until determination of damages. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (102Kb) Microsoft Word document (70.5 Kb)
30/07/2003	CA & R76/03 ECJ: 008/2006	Lesley Scholtz and The State Froneman J Intoxication as defence for criminal liabilty causes tension between the underlying principle that people should only be punished for actions committed by making a voluntary decision as oppose to the normative function of criminal law in setting standards of which the enforcement cannot exclusively depend on the defendants personal decision. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document Microsoft Word document
17/4/2003	R 20021774	S v Ndyumbu Plasket AJ and Froneman J Plea of guilty -- Not permissible to draw inferences from explanation in terms of s112 of the CPA Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (7.33Kb) Microsoft Word document (22.5 Kb)
11/4/2003	511/03	Victoria Park Ratepayers' Association v Greyvenouw CC and others Plasket AJ and Jennett AJP Contempt of court -- practice -- rule nis -- urgency -- merits and sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (124Kb) Microsoft Word document (108 Kb)
10/4/2003	CA&R 490/02	S v Jafta Leach and Pickering JJ (Erasmus J dissenting) Constitutional Law - Majority view - s. 172 (1)(a) and (b) of the Constitution are to read conjunctively and not disjunctively (Erasmus J dissenting) - Constitutional Court having made an order under s. 172(1)(b) in S v Steyn 2001 (1) SA 1146 (CC) suspending the declaration of invalidity relating to s. 309 B and 309 C of the Criminal Procedure Act - no room for this Court to make a further order under s. 172 (1)(b). Criminal Procedure - right of appeal of an accused convicted and sentenced in the Magistrate's Court on or before 28 May 2001 whereafter the declaration of invalidity in S v Steyn came into effect - the declaration of invalidity not retrospective in effect and only effective as from 29 May 2001 - accused persons convicted and sentenced before that date having to apply for leave to appeal under s. 309 B or 309 C - the approach in S v Jaars 2002 (1) SACR 546 (C) approved while that followed in S v Thusi 2002 (12) BCLR 1274 (N) and S v Danster 2002 (2) SACR 178 (C) disapproved. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (256Kb) Microsoft Word document (146Kb)
4/4/2003	CA& R 769	Soweya and another v S Plasket AJ Housebreaking with intent to steal and theft -- whether state proved its case beyond reasonable doubt -- sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (12.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (30.5 Kb)
4/4/2003	CA&R 862/02	Cela v S Plasket AJ and Jennett AJP Robbery -- sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (14.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (29Kb)
3/4/2003	CA404/2002	Ndongeni and another v S Plasket AJ, Erasmus and Chetty JJ Rape -- sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (36Kb) Microsoft Word document (40Kb)
31/3/2003	CA&R 839/02	Busakwe v S Plasket AJ and Pickering J Sentence -- Roberry -- Proof of robbery with aggravating circumstances Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (20.7Kb) Microsoft Word document (35.5Kb)
27/3/2003	452/03	Van Greunen v Sigma Switchboard Manufacturing CC Plasket AJ Practice -- winding up applications and urgency Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (17.1Kb) Microsoft Word document (29Kb)
	CA&R 20558	Mondo v S Plasket A J and Pickering J Theft -- Sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (21Kb) Microsoft Word document (35.5Kb)
13/3/2003	CA&R 693/02	Luwani and another v State Plasket AJ and Erasmus J The right to legal representation -- Sentence, and when pre-sentence reports are require Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (64.1Kb) Microsoft Word document (61Kb)
11/3/2003	2301/02	Premier Freight (Pty) Ltd v Breathetex Corporation (Pty) Ltd Plasket AJ Discovery in Motion Proceedings Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (42.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (45Kb)
5/3/2003	CA&R 473/02	Koopman v S Plasket A J and Pillay AJ Murder -- whether state proved its case beyond reasonable doubt Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (36.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (60.5Kb)
5/3/2003	CA&R 845/02	Kleinbooi v S Plasket A J and "Pillay AJ Culpable Homicide -- Sentence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (12.9Kb) Microsoft Word document (26Kb)
	CC15/02	S v Fourie and others Leach J Criminal Law and Procedure - accused convicted in Regional Court but committed for sentence by High Court under s. 52 (1) of the Criminal Procedure Act - after sentence in the High Court the accused applied for leave to appeal against conviction - distinction between the procedures under s. 52 where the accused is convicted pursuant to a plea of guilty in the Regional Court and that where he has pleaded not guilty - whether in the High Court it is necessary for the judge to confirm a conviction where the accused has pleaded not guilty - ain this latter case the judgment of the Regional Court is not to beequated with that of the High Court in regard to conviction and the accused enjoys an automatic right of appeal from his conviction in the Regional Court but requires leave of the High Court to appeal against sentence - the anomalies of the situation highlighted and the hope expressed that the legislature will remedy deficiencies in the legislation. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (47.7Kb) Microsoft Word document (59Kb)
	CA149/2001	Ndwandwa v Auto & General Insurance Co Ltd Leach J Civil Procedure - application for condonation of late prosecution of appeal and late filing of heads of argument - requirements of such an application and factors to be taken into account. Insurance Law - Insurance company relying upon a claim at the failure to claim within the time limitation clause - plaintiff contending the insurance contract entered into telephonically did not contain such a clause - plaintiff bear the onus of establishing the contract did not contain such a clause contract- plaintiff failing to establish that the contract did not contain the time limitation clause as contended by the insurance company. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (37.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (39.5Kb)
21/2/2003	3263/02	Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality v Greyvenouw CC Plasket AJ Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (168Kb) Microsoft Word document (123Kb)
20/2/2003	013/2004	Seychelles Shipping Lines Ltd v Taurus International Ltd and Claremont Farming CC Sandi J Attachment of found jurisdiction Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (64.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (43.5Kb)
17/02/2003	CA 96/2001 ECJ: 033/2005	Galelekile Patrick Mcinga and Auto & General Insurance Company (Ltd) Erasmus, Leach and Sandi JJ Appeal with the leave of Ludorf, J against the whole of his judgement in twhich he dismissed the appelant's claim. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (72.9Kb) Microsoft Word document (61.5Kb)
	Rev020557	S v January Plasket AJ Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (4.98Kb) Microsoft Word document (22Kb)
06/2/2003	CA &R 1/03	Phiri v S Plasket AJ Bail appeal Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (27.2Kb) Microsoft Word document (35.5Kb)
06/2/2003	3092/2002	SA Forestry Co Ltd v Kareedouw Municipality Plasket AJ Application for summary judgment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (28.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (35.5Kb)
09/1/2003	CA540/2002	Communication Specialists CC v Poulter Leach and Mhlantla JJ Delict – claim for injuria – allegation that a businessman had acted unethically, deviously and in a matter worthy of censure or rebuke constitutes an actionable injuria – although not a case of de minimis, damages of no more than R1 000,00 justified in all the circumstances. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (56Kb) Microsoft Word document (47Kb)
2002	Back to Top
07/10/2002	959/2002	First Rand Bank Ltd v Van der Merwe Froneman J Constitutionality of rule 49(13) of High Court rules - referred to full court Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (22.7Kb) Microsoft Word document (30.5Kb)
29/8/2002	546/2002	Margre Property Holdings CC v Jewula Pickering J Extension of security tenure Act – Eviction – whether High court as jurisdiction to order same – occupier of farm has no right to graze livestock without owner’s prior consent. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (108Kb) Microsoft Word document (82.5Kb)
22/8/2002	1601/01	Nick's Fishmonger Holdings (Pty) Ltd v De Sousa Kroon J Claim and Counterclaim in Contract – Contract providing that disputes thereunder be decide by arbitration – whether order should issue staying proceedings pending determination of disputes by arbitrator Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (28.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (34.5Kb)
06/08/2002	2696/01	Cutting v The Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality Kroon J Action for damages – Pedestrian injured in consequence of stepping into an uncovered fire hydrant hole in pavement within municipal area – liability of local authority Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (47.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (52.5Kb)
08/8/2002	1362/02	Graham NO and others v Trackstar Trading 363 (Pty) Ltd Kroon J Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (192Kb) Microsoft Word document (150Kb)
08/8/2002	678/02	The Reclamation Group (Pty) Ltd v Smit and others Froneman J Evidentiary requirements on reconsideration under Rule 6(12)(c) of an Anton Piller order Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (52.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (50Kb)
10/06/2002	R: 65/2001	Jongisile Fojana v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accident Fund and The Road Accident Fund Ebrahim J Civil Trial for Damages Adobe Acrobat (pdf) Document Microsoft Word Document
22/5/2002	CA344/2002	Qoko v La Grange and others Jones and Pickering JJ Review of conviction and sentence following plea of guilty - plea allegedly induced by police threats and a promise of a light sentence - onus on applicant on review. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (48.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (48Kb)
30/5/2002	CA35/2002	Coetzee v Whitfield Leach and Jansen JJ Contract – alleged tacit term obliging purchaser to pay VAT on a sale of property – no evidence of surrounding circumstances but permissable to have regard to statutory framework whereunder VAT is paid – in light of statute, no room to imply alleged tacit term. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (59.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (49.9Kb)
29/5/2002	430/2000	Poultney v Absa Brokers (Pty) Ltd and another Kroon J Claim for damages – alleged failure by expert financial adviser to comply with required standard of skill in giving advice – claim in contract, alternatively in delict. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (138Kb) Microsoft Word document (92.5Kb)
23/5/2002	CA590/2001	Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Heron Heights CC Kroon, Leach and Pillay JJ Income tax – proceeds of sale of land – whether capital accrual or revenue receipt. Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (103Kb) Microsoft Word document (68.5Kb)
26/4/2002	98/02	Ramsamy v Minister of Home Affairs Froneman J Aliens Control Act Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (18.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (29.5Kb)
26/4/2002	332/02	Chima v Minister of Home Affairs Froneman J Illegal Alien seeking tempory residence permit Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (38.3Kb) Microsoft Word document (36Kb)
26/4/2002	790/01	Mashiya v Matshikawe Froneman and Leach JJ Committal to prison for contempt of court Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (25.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (36Kb)
25/4/2002	63/02	SA Shore Angling Association v Minister of Environmental Affairs & Tourism Erasmus J Vehicles in coastal zone Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (96.8Kb) Microsoft Word document (72.5Kb)
24/4/2002	CA247/2001	Siyotula v S Jones, Nepgen and Pickering JJ Special review Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (39.7Kb) Microsoft Word document (44Kb)
24/4/2002	CA&R520/01	S v Matwa Leach and Jones JJ Evidence - admissibility of dock ID Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (87.3Kb) Microsoft Word document (64.5Kb)
12/4/2002	013/2004 81/2001	Biggs v Biggs Erasmus J Divorce Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (61Kb) Microsoft Word document (46.5Kb)
11/4/2002	247/2001	Minister of Safety and Security v Liddell Jones and Pillay JJ Wrongful arrest Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (44.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (47Kb)
28/2/2002	1898/96	Willemse v Whitney Farming Enterprises Jones J Damages, negligence Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (43.3Kb) Microsoft Word document (44.5Kb)
21/2/2002	1371/2000	Ntswahlana + 252 v White Commission Leach and Nepgen JJ Constitution Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (115Kb) Microsoft Word document (73Kb)
13/2/2002	2269/99	Mackay v Legal Aid Board Jones J Claim for professional fees Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (141Kb) Microsoft Word document (128Kb)
	2155/97	Sackstein NO v D-G, Dept of Education & Training, Bisho Van Rensburg J Application for substitution as plaintiffs Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (47.3Kb) Microsoft Word document (44Kb)
	408/2001	Makoba v Van Tonder Pickering J and Goso AJ Damages - special plea of prescription Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (51.4Kb) Microsoft Word document (49.5Kb)
2001	Back to Top
14/12/2001	1277/2001	Nkonkobe Municipality v Water Services SA (Pty) Ltd Pickering J Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (89.6Kb) Microsoft Word document (50Kb)
07/9/2001	CA 1/2001	Wait v Minister of Defence Pickering, Jennett and Jones JJ Minister of Defence - course and scope of employment Adobe Acrobat (pdf) document (71.5Kb) Microsoft Word document (58.5Kb)
	Back to Top